John F. MacArthur, the influential pastor of Grace Community Church in Sun Valley, California, is currently hospitalized with a severe case of pneumonia as of July 2025. This health crisis has reignited public interest in MacArthur’s previous controversies, including allegations of mishandling abuse claims within his congregation and his contentious stance during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Background on John MacArthur
MacArthur has long been recognized as a prominent figure in American evangelicalism, founding the radio and television program Grace to You. Over the years, he has garnered a reputation for his strict adherence to biblical teachings, which has attracted both fervent supporters and vocal critics.
In 2022, MacArthur faced serious allegations regarding his treatment of a female church member who reported domestic abuse. This incident allegedly occurred in 2002 when the woman sought help from church leaders, only to be excommunicated after leaving her abusive husband. Reports indicate that MacArthur instructed his congregation to view her as an “unbeliever,” stating, “This is what the Lord wants… He wants discipline… to be publicly shamed, to be put away from fellowship,” according to The Roys Report.
Controversy During the COVID-19 Pandemic
MacArthur’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic also drew significant backlash. He openly challenged the severity of the crisis, declaring, “There is no pandemic,” during a time when many were adhering to public health guidelines. His refusal to close the church led to a lawsuit from Los Angeles County, which sought to enforce health regulations that MacArthur defied. In response, he countersued, claiming violations of religious freedom.
The legal battle concluded with a settlement in which Los Angeles County and the state of California each agreed to pay MacArthur $400,000, totaling $800,000 for both parties. The county stated that the decision to resolve the litigation was necessary following a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that limited public health measures on houses of worship.
Current Health Status and Previous Issues
As his health deteriorates, MacArthur’s congregation has expressed concern. Tom Patton, the associate pastor at Grace Community Church, informed the church that MacArthur had been admitted to the hospital due to pneumonia and suggested that he may be nearing the end of his life. This announcement follows a series of health issues MacArthur has faced, including a diagnosis of atrial fibrillation in 2023, which required surgery for cardiac stents and catheter insertion.
Throughout 2024, he underwent multiple surgeries, including an aorta replacement and a procedure to address fluid buildup in his lungs. Earlier in 2025, he spent approximately two weeks in the hospital for kidney, lung, and heart-related issues.
As MacArthur battles pneumonia, many in his congregation and the broader community are reflecting on his legacy, marked by both influential teachings and significant controversies.
