UPDATE: Comedian John Mulaney was spotted at the U.S. Supreme Court on November 5, 2025, as justices heard crucial arguments regarding President Donald Trump’s controversial tariffs. Mulaney attended to support his friend and lawyer Neal Katyal, who represented companies challenging the legality of these tariffs.
The Supreme Court’s nine justices engaged in a heated debate over whether Trump overstepped his authority by imposing sweeping tariffs on nearly every country. This landmark case could redefine executive power and its limits, making Mulaney’s presence even more significant.
Akhil Reed Amar, a renowned Constitutional law scholar and mutual friend of Mulaney and Katyal, emphasized Mulaney’s deep interest in law, stating, “John is far more than a world-class theatrical talent; he is a serious public intellectual.” Mulaney has previously discussed Constitutional law with Katyal on the lawyer’s podcast, showcasing his genuine passion for legal matters.
Katyal, who is also a former Acting U.S. Solicitor General, argued on behalf of two groups of companies, asserting that Trump misused the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose the tariffs. The stakes are high as this case could set critical precedents for future executive actions.
After the arguments wrapped up, Mulaney shared a humorous illustration on social media, captioning it, “Cheap seats but a great show,” highlighting his unique perspective on the proceedings.
Katyal revealed earlier this year that he is collaborating with Mulaney on a television show about the Supreme Court, described as a “West Wing for the Supreme Court.” This project aims to use the arts to inspire discussions about justice and governance.
Mulaney’s legal background runs deep; both of his parents are attorneys. His mother, Ellen Mulaney, is a former law professor at Northwestern University, while his father, Charles Mulaney, is a corporate lawyer at Skadden Arps. This familial influence has undoubtedly fueled Mulaney’s interest in Constitutional law.
Interestingly, this is not the first time Mulaney has found himself in the company of Supreme Court justices. He previously moderated a session at a 2024 Yale Law School reunion, where Justice Sonia Sotomayor was in attendance. The event focused on textualist approaches to Constitutional interpretation.
As the Supreme Court arguments concluded, Mulaney was noted for his engagement despite not taking the mic. The proceedings featured moments of levity, including remarks from Justice Samuel Alito, who ribbed Katyal about his nondelegation argument, eliciting laughter from attendees.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh also contributed humorously, pointing out a perceived flaw in the argument presented by Oregon Solicitor General Benjamin Gutman, who argued against the tariffs on behalf of twelve states. Gutman quipped back that taxes and tariffs are distinct, leading to more laughter from the audience.
As the legal landscape shifts, all eyes remain on the Supreme Court’s ruling, which could redefine the boundaries of presidential power. Mulaney’s involvement not only highlights his commitment to civic engagement but also adds a unique cultural angle to a case that could affect millions.
Stay tuned for more updates as this story develops and impacts unfold.
