Kaitlyn Bristowe, co-host of the new dating show Are You My First?, candidly discussed her first experience with intimacy during a recent episode. When asked by fellow host Colton Underwood to describe her first time in three words, she responded with a straightforward assessment: “scary, painful and terrible.” This exchange highlights the show’s premise, which revolves around the experiences of individuals navigating their first romantic encounters.
While playing a game designed to elicit personal stories, Colton, 33, sought further details from Kaitlyn, 40. She shared a memorable moment from her first kiss, recalling that a song by the band Five was playing at the time. “Baby, when the lights go out,” she sang, referencing the group’s 1998 hit, “When the Lights Go Out.” Kaitlyn’s recollection of her first sexual encounter was starkly different, describing it as an experience filled with “awkward silence on the couch.”
Kaitlyn revealed that her first time took place on a couch that had been passed down from her parents, a poignant detail that added a layer of personal history. “Honestly, it was like a horror film, and I say this with love,” she remarked, explaining that the encounter was with her high school sweetheart. Despite her affection for him, she noted that she suffers from vaginismus, a medical condition that involves involuntary muscle contractions and can cause significant discomfort during intimacy.
The conversation took a turn as Kaitlyn elaborated on her initial expectations of a romantic moment, contrasting them with the reality she faced. “It’s not going to be sexy,” she advised, sharing insights for those who may be experiencing similar situations. “It’s messy, but so is love,” she concluded, offering a realistic perspective on intimacy.
Colton responded positively to Kaitlyn’s advice, indicating that her insights would resonate with the audience. Both hosts have personal ties to the world of reality television, with Colton having been a virgin during his season as The Bachelor and Kaitlyn previously hosting The Bachelorette. Their shared experiences lend credibility to their discussions on the show.
The goal of Are You My First? is not merely to facilitate physical experiences but to foster emotional connections. Colton explained, “The goal was never to get them laid… The goal is to connect with somebody, to experience these things.” He emphasized that many participants discovered deeper self-acceptance and understanding of their virginity throughout the series.
Currently streaming on Hulu, Are You My First? invites viewers into the personal journeys of its contestants as they explore their first romantic encounters. Their stories, filled with vulnerability and humor, resonate with a broader audience navigating similar experiences in their own lives. The show aims to create an open dialogue about intimacy, love, and the realities of first times in a way that is both engaging and relatable.
