Lacey Chabert and Andrew Walker are set to star together in the Hallmark Channel’s upcoming Christmas movie, She’s Making a List. The announcement was made on July 19, 2025, during a promotional event for the network’s annual Countdown to Christmas programming. This film marks a reunion for the two fan-favorite actors, who previously collaborated on the 2018 film My Secret Valentine.
The plot centers around Isabel Haynes, portrayed by Chabert, who works as a naughty or nice list auditor. The storyline takes a turn when she is assigned to evaluate an 11-year-old named Charlie Duncan, played by a yet-to-be-named actor. Isabel’s task becomes complicated as she develops feelings for Charlie’s father, Jason Duncan, played by Walker. The Hallmark Channel teased the film’s premise, stating, “Can naughty or nice list auditor Isabel put her feelings aside for single dad Jason and his struggling daughter?”
In a post on social media, Chabert expressed her excitement about the project, commenting, “So excited about this! ❤️🎄” The film is scheduled to premiere later this year as part of the network’s holiday programming, promising to blend humor, romance, and festive spirit.
Cast and Crew Reactions
Both actors have shared their enthusiasm for working together again. Chabert emphasized the joy of reuniting with Walker after several years, noting, “Andrew brings so much heart, humor, and warmth to every role, and working with him again felt like coming home.” Walker reciprocated the sentiment, praising Chabert’s talent by calling her the “Queen of Christmas.” He remarked, “What a gift it is to reunite with Lacey seven years after our Valentine’s movie. She brings warmth, heart, and comedy with such ease.”
This collaboration illustrates Hallmark’s ongoing strategy of pairing beloved stars in heartwarming stories that resonate with audiences during the holiday season. The film’s mix of romance and holiday themes aligns with the network’s tradition of delivering feel-good content that appeals to family viewers.
As excitement builds for She’s Making a List, fans of Chabert and Walker can look forward to a heartwarming tale that promises to capture the essence of the holiday spirit. The film is part of Hallmark’s broader initiative to celebrate Christmas through storytelling that emphasizes love, connection, and the joy of the season.
