New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani is facing significant backlash following the resurfacing of a video clip from March 2023, in which he controversially compared the New York Police Department (NYPD) to the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). The remarks, made during a panel at the Democratic Socialists of America’s national convention, have reignited discussions about his past statements regarding law enforcement and prompted calls for clarification on his stance.
In the video, Mamdani stated, “We have to make clear that when the boot of the NYPD is on your neck, it’s been laced by the IDF.” This statement has drawn sharp criticism from various quarters, with detractors arguing that it trivializes serious issues and fosters division. Prominent figures on social media quickly condemned the comments, framing them as antisemitic. Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, characterized Mamdani’s remarks as “sick” and divisive. He emphasized the dangers of conflating domestic law enforcement with military actions overseas.
Mamdani’s comments prompted him to issue an apology during a subsequent appearance on Fox News, where he distanced himself from his previous remarks. “I just wanted to address a couple of the questions,” he said, reiterating that he aims to work collaboratively with police to ensure public safety. He acknowledged the ongoing retention crisis within the NYPD, noting that approximately 350 officers leave the department each month.
In a follow-up press event in Hell’s Kitchen, Mamdani reaffirmed his commitment to addressing public safety issues without compromising on his views about the NYPD. He stated, “I’m looking forward to ensuring that police officers are only asked to do the work of a police department, not the work of social services.” This marks a shift in rhetoric from his previous calls to defund the police, which have drawn scrutiny from both allies and opponents.
Critics of Mamdani have expressed concern over his proposals to reform policing in New York City. His suggestion to have social workers and other non-police professionals handle certain 911 calls has sparked debate among law enforcement experts. Joseph Giacalone, a retired NYPD sergeant, labeled the idea as “the worst I’ve heard in a while,” raising concerns about potential risks if dispatchers misjudge situations.
Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo also weighed in, criticizing Mamdani for his divisive approach and emphasizing the need for unity in leadership. “You can’t be a divisive leader in this city,” Cuomo stated. “You have to be united.”
Mamdani’s comments have not only drawn ire from opponents but have also raised questions about his ability to lead in a city that often grapples with complex social and public safety issues. As the mayoral race progresses, his past statements and proposed policies are likely to remain central themes in the campaign.
The controversy surrounding Mamdani highlights the broader conversations about policing, community safety, and the political landscape in New York City. With the election just around the corner, voters will be assessing candidates’ positions on these pressing issues, making Mamdani’s ability to navigate this backlash crucial to his campaign’s success.
As Mamdani continues to respond to criticism, the implications of his remarks will undoubtedly resonate within the city’s political discourse, influencing not only his campaign but also the future of law enforcement in New York.
