UPDATE: The NYC Parks Department has issued an urgent vacate order to the operators of a controversial anti-Israel community garden in Ridgewood, Queens. The Sunset Community Garden leaders must leave by September 3, 2023, following months of legal disputes and complaints of antisemitism.
This decisive action comes after increasing public outcry and a commitment from city officials to ensure that community spaces remain inclusive. Mayor Eric Adams stated, “There is no place for hate in New York City, and our community gardens should be safe, inclusive, and welcoming spaces for all New Yorkers.” He emphasized that the garden’s leaders had barred individuals who support Israel from using a city-owned public space.
The garden, initially created as a non-political initiative in September 2023, soon became embroiled in anti-Israel sentiment, leading to its controversial reputation. A special section of the space was labeled “Poppies 4 Palestine,” further highlighting its political leanings. The NYC Parks Department had revoked the garden’s license on May 5, citing a breach of contract, but the leaders sought legal protection, temporarily stalling the eviction process.
On June 4, a judge granted a temporary restraining order allowing the garden to remain operational, but this order has now been lifted, enabling the Parks Department to proceed with the removal. The eviction marks the end of a four-month struggle that began with allegations of discrimination against attendees who support Israel.
Garden organizer Laura Merrick attempted to rebrand the space as “Jardin de Santa Cecilia” in honor of Latina trans advocate Cecilia Gentili, who is commemorated with altars within the garden. Despite the changes, the controversy surrounding the garden has not dissipated, and Merrick’s group has filed a federal discrimination lawsuit against the Parks Department, which remains unresolved.
Residents and city officials alike are watching closely as the September deadline approaches. The Parks Department’s actions signal a broader commitment to eliminating hate in public spaces and ensuring all community members feel welcome.
The situation is evolving rapidly, and further developments are expected as the deadline approaches. Stay tuned for updates on this urgent matter that impacts both local residents and broader community dynamics.
