In a significant move for the San Francisco Giants, Buster Posey, the newly appointed president of baseball operations, has expressed strong confidence in the team’s new manager, Tony Vitello. Vitello, who previously led the University of Tennessee to national prominence, officially joined the Giants last week, marking a notable transition from college to professional baseball.
From College Coach to Major League Manager
Vitello’s journey to this role has been remarkable. During his first year as an assistant coach at the University of Arkansas, he witnessed Posey in action during the 2014 World Series at Kauffman Stadium, where Posey played a pivotal role in securing the Giants’ third championship in five years. Reflecting on that intense experience, Vitello remarked, “It was rather intense, correct?” to which Posey responded with a smile, “I’ll second that. It was.”
Since that championship, the Giants have faced challenges, remaining a .500 team with playoff appearances in 2016 and 2021 but failing to progress beyond the National League Division Series. Now, as the 40th manager in franchise history, Vitello understands the weight of expectations and the legacy he inherits. He noted the illustrious figures in Giants history, including Bruce Bochy and Barry Bonds, stating, “There are very high expectations, very high standards to meet because of the past.”
Risk and Reward in Vitello’s Hiring
Posey’s decision to hire Vitello carries inherent risks. At 47, Vitello has never managed or played at the professional level, having spent years as an assistant at various colleges before his tenure at Tennessee. The upcoming season will be his first managing a professional team, with the Giants set to face the New York Yankees for Opening Day next year.
Financially, the Giants have made a substantial commitment. Vitello’s contract includes an annual salary of $3.5 million over three years, with a vesting option for a fourth year. Additionally, the team paid a $3 million buyout to secure his services from Tennessee. This investment comes after the Giants also incurred a $4 million expense by picking up former manager Bob Melvin‘s option before his dismissal in September.
Despite the uncertainties, Posey believes Vitello possesses key qualities of a successful leader. “He checked all the boxes: teacher, motivator, tireless worker, and someone who understands how to build culture,” Posey stated. He emphasized, “We believe his leadership is not only going to impact our clubhouse, but it’s also going to impact our organization and our entire fan base as well.”
Posey acknowledged the potential backlash should the decision not yield results, saying, “If this, for some reason, doesn’t work, then people are going to look back and say, ‘Well, that was a dumb decision.’” Nevertheless, he remains optimistic about the partnership, asserting, “I have full confidence this is going to be a great relationship.”
Emphasizing Intensity and Building Relationships
Vitello’s coaching style is known for its intensity, characterized by a fierce passion for the game. His approach at Tennessee included moments of high emotion, such as celebrating victories with exuberance. Posey appreciates this edge, suggesting that the Giants could benefit from a more spirited atmosphere. “As a fan, I want there to be a little bit of friction at times,” he explained. “There’s an edge to be had with that type of mentality, and it’s something that he’ll bring.”
Transitioning from college to the major leagues presents unique challenges, particularly regarding the extensive schedule. While Vitello managed around 60 games per season at Tennessee, he will now oversee a grueling 162-game season, not including spring training and potential postseason play. Acknowledging the unknowns, he stated, “There are a lot of unknowns and a lot of wonder in my mind.” He intends to lean on his coaching staff for support as he navigates his inaugural season in the major leagues.
Building relationships with the Giants’ veteran players will also be essential. Vitello has begun informal discussions with some teammates and aims to foster stronger connections before spring training begins. “I think we all want the same thing: to win,” he concluded, emphasizing the shared goal among players and management.
As Vitello prepares for this new chapter, he is ready to earn respect through hard work and dedication. “It’s a lot of lonely nights in a hotel,” he remarked, reflecting on the dedication necessary for success in a demanding environment. With the upcoming season promising both challenges and opportunities, the Giants and their fans look forward to seeing how this new leadership will shape the team’s future.
