The Benson School District in Minnesota will retain its use of the “Braves” mascot after receiving an exemption from the Upper Sioux Community. This decision allows the district to continue using the mascot, which has represented Benson Schools since 1945. The exemption comes in light of recent changes in state legislation regarding American Indian mascots in schools.
During the 2022-23 legislative session, a law was passed requiring schools with American Indian mascots to discontinue their usage by September 1, 2025, unless exemptions were granted by all eleven tribal nations in Minnesota and the Tribal Nations Education Committee. The Benson School District initially sought an exemption, but two tribes and the committee rejected their request. However, a subsequent legislative amendment allowed districts to seek exemptions from the nearest tribal community.
The Benson School Board engaged with the Upper Sioux Community Board of Trustees, emphasizing how the mascot is utilized in a respectful manner to inspire students towards good character and academic success. Benson Superintendent of Schools Dennis Laumeyer expressed appreciation for the support from the Upper Sioux Community, stating, “We are deeply grateful to the Upper Sioux Community for their understanding and appreciation for the way Benson Schools uses the mascot in a respectful and honorable manner.”
Throughout Benson’s elementary school, the “Braves Way” initiative promotes positive values, encouraging students to “B respectful, B engaged, B my best.” The conversation with tribal trustees was described as collaborative, with the Upper Sioux Community showing readiness to assist Benson Schools in meeting state educational requirements concerning Indigenous peoples, particularly the Dakota.
Community support played a significant role in the decision to seek the exemption. Laumeyer indicated that discussions about the mascot had been ongoing for over two years, with feedback overwhelmingly favoring its retention. Alumni expressed that losing the mascot would feel like losing a part of their school identity.
Another critical factor in the decision was the potential financial burden associated with changing the mascot and logo. Laumeyer estimated that replacing the mascot could cost around $1 million. This figure encompasses the need to update athletic uniforms, scoreboards, furniture, gym floors, and additional school materials. The legislation did not allocate funding for schools to facilitate this change, which would divert resources from educational programs.
To mitigate potential financial strain, the district is also exploring the adoption of a four-day school week, which could yield cost savings while maintaining educational offerings.
The Benson School District’s decision reflects a commitment to honoring the mascot’s legacy while fostering positive relationships with the local Indigenous community. The collaboration with the Upper Sioux Community signifies a path forward that respects both tradition and contemporary educational values.
